---
title: "Disturbance loss in NSW compulsory acquisition"
description: "How NSW compulsory acquisition law treats relocation, duty, mortgage and other disturbance costs, and the evidence needed to support a claim."
canonical: https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/
language: en-AU
last_updated: 2026-11-21
source_revision: 498ccea127247fe38494c2df5ab784af20b5625f
publisher: "Stone & Pillar Legal"
---

[Compulsory acquisition](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/topic/compulsory-acquisition/)

# Disturbance loss in NSW compulsory acquisition

- Published

  21 November 2026

- By

  Michael Themis, Principal Solicitor

- Jurisdiction

  New South Wales

How NSW compulsory acquisition law treats relocation, duty, mortgage and other disturbance costs, and the evidence needed to support a claim.

![Aerial view of an industrial estate of warehouses stretching towards a city skyline](https://stonepillar.com.au/_astro/AdobeStock_1564742149.BQVjDKle_ZYHBKh.webp)

On this page

- [The six disturbance categories](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/#the-six-disturbance-categories)
- [Each claimed cost must be placed within the statutory definition](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/#each-claimed-cost-must-be-placed-within-the-statutory-definition)
- [Paragraph (f) is confined by its context and structure](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/#paragraph-f-is-confined-by-its-context-and-structure)
- [Stamp duty and mortgage costs stay within their paragraphs](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/#stamp-duty-and-mortgage-costs-stay-within-their-paragraphs)
- [Relocation is not a guarantee of like-for-like premises](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/#relocation-is-not-a-guarantee-of-like-for-like-premises)
- [Evidence remains decisive](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/#evidence-remains-decisive)
- [Building a disturbance schedule](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/#building-a-disturbance-schedule)
- [A government review of the Act is under way](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disturbance-loss-compulsory-acquisition/#a-government-review-of-the-act-is-under-way)

The _Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991_ (NSW) does not compensate disruption in general. [Section 59](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) defines “loss attributable to disturbance” through six specific categories. Each category has its own language, and recent NSW Court of Appeal decisions require those limits to be applied closely.

Compulsory acquisition can cause financial loss beyond the value of the interest taken. A household may need removal and storage services. A business may need to move equipment, operate temporarily from another site or incur other costs tied to its existing use of the land.

This article concerns [section 59](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) financial loss. It does not address the separate, non-financial head of [disadvantage resulting from relocation](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disadvantage-resulting-from-relocation-nsw/) under [section 60](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.60) .

## The six disturbance categories

[Section 55(d)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.55) makes disturbance one of the statutory compensation heads. Under [section 59(1)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) , loss attributable to disturbance means any of the following:

1. **Legal costs:** legal costs reasonably incurred by the persons entitled to compensation in connection with the compulsory acquisition.
2. **Valuation fees:** fees of a qualified valuer reasonably incurred in connection with the compulsory acquisition, excluding fees calculated by reference to the value of the land as assessed by the valuer.
3. **Relocation costs:** the category quoted below, which turns on costs incurred in connection with relocating the persons entitled to compensation.
4. **Stamp duty:** costs reasonably incurred, or that might reasonably be incurred, in purchasing land for relocation, capped by reference to land of equivalent value to the acquired land.
5. **Mortgage costs:** costs reasonably incurred, or that might reasonably be incurred, in discharging a mortgage and executing a new mortgage resulting from relocation. They are capped at the amount that would be incurred if the new mortgage secured only the balance owing under the discharged mortgage.
6. **Other financial costs:** any other financial costs reasonably incurred, or that might reasonably be incurred, relating to the actual use of the land, as a direct and natural consequence of the acquisition.

A valuer must be qualified within [section 59(2)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59-ssec.2) , subject to the regulations. The claimant should check that requirement when engaging the valuer.

The categories are narrowly defined. [Paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) is not a general power to compensate every financial effect of acquisition, and it cannot be used to avoid a limit Parliament placed in an earlier paragraph.

[Section 59(1)(c)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) defines the relocation category as:

> “financial costs reasonably incurred in connection with the relocation of those persons (including legal costs but not including stamp duty or mortgage costs)”

## Each claimed cost must be placed within the statutory definition

Six questions apply to each item:

1. **Claimant and category:** who incurred the cost, and which paragraph of [section 59](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) applies?
2. **Actual use:** how did the claimant itself use the land at acquisition? For [paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) , the use must generally be the claimant’s own existing use, rather than a proposed use. A tenant’s or subsidiary’s use does not, without more, establish use by the owner. In [_Alexandria Landfill Pty Ltd v Transport for NSW_ (2020) 103 NSWLR 479; \[2020\] NSWCA 165](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/173b15bd3b9a862e6d1d4d33) , the Court of Appeal noted that the trial court had not required “a physical or active use”, but had used the statutory language of an “actual use”: \[105], \[358].
3. **Causation:** what connects the cost to the acquisition, rather than to the broader public project or a separate commercial decision?
4. **Reasonableness:** were the scope, amount, alternatives and timing proportionate?
5. **Overlap:** has the same loss already been reflected in another disturbance paragraph, market value or reinstatement? [Section 61](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.61) adds a separate rule where market value is assessed on the basis that the land could be used for a purpose other than its current use. Compensation is then not payable for “any financial advantage that would necessarily have been forgone in realising that potential” or for “any financial loss that would necessarily have been incurred in realising that potential”.
6. **Proof:** do the engagement, quote, invoice, calculation, payment record and causal explanation establish the claim?

A spreadsheet total is not enough if it does not show why each item satisfies the relevant paragraph.

## [Paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) is confined by its context and structure

The leading authorities treat [section 59](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) as a structured and limited definition.

In [_Roads and Maritime Services (NSW) v United Petroleum Pty Ltd_ (2019) 99 NSWLR 279; \[2019\] NSWCA 41](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/5c7d9c75e4b02a5a800bf062) at \[9], Basten JA said that reading “any other financial costs” in isolation disregarded “four different forms of constraint imposed by the context and structure of the section”. Macfarlan JA agreed at \[72]. Payne JA agreed at \[73], subject to the qualification concerning overlap between the statutory heads explained at \[74].

In the same case, Sackville AJA concluded at \[118] that, because one month’s notice was required to end the tenancy, “only the loss of one month’s profits” could fairly be characterised as a direct and natural consequence of the acquisition. The majority, however, held that the primary judge was in error in allowing any amount for the termination of the business: \[16]–\[17], \[54]. Preston CJ of the Land and Environment Court said at \[130] that the phrases in [paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) must be read “together as a composite clause”, and explained at \[160]–\[161] why the perpetual-profits award could not stand. The appeal was allowed, the judgment in United Petroleum’s favour was set aside and its application was dismissed: \[71]. Payne JA, like Sackville AJA, doubted whether lost profits are “financial costs” at all, while agreeing that the question should await a case in which the Court of Appeal’s decision in _El Boustani v_ _Minister Administering the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979_ \[2014] NSWCA 33 is directly challenged: \[76]–\[78].

The decision interpreted [paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) in the setting of a tenancy at will terminable on one month’s notice. It does not establish that business loss can never be compensable. The claimant must prove a financial cost within the statutory language, connected to the actual use of the acquired land and caused in the required way. [Paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) cannot recreate the value of an interest the claimant did not hold. Paragraph (f) has not been amended since that decision.

The Court of Appeal returned to the issue in [_Alexandria Landfill Pty Ltd v Transport for NSW_ (2020) 103 NSWLR 479; \[2020\] NSWCA 165](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/173b15bd3b9a862e6d1d4d33) . Basten JA construed paragraph (f) as excluding the lost opportunity to earn future profits and considered costs under paragraph (c) confined to expenditure: \[137] to \[139]. Leeming JA agreed with the relevant reasoning: \[416]. In [_The Trustee for Whitcurt Unit Trust v Transport for NSW_ \[2021\] NSWLEC 82](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/17aebde5b70aa79dbab42448) , however, the Court left the paragraph (c) relocation-profit question unresolved, describing the relevant observations as obiter, meaning observations not necessary to decide the case: \[152]. Relocation-related lost-profit claims under paragraph (c) therefore need separate analysis; the later decision did not settle their availability.

## Stamp duty and mortgage costs stay within their paragraphs

In [_Sydney Metro v G & J Drivas Pty Ltd_ (2024) 113 NSWLR 429; \[2024\] NSWCA 5](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/18d5868626aa8267ce013eb7) , Kirk JA recorded at \[109] the respondents’ acceptance of Basten JA’s formulation in [_United Petroleum_ at \[14\]](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/5c7d9c75e4b02a5a800bf062) : [paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) must not be construed to “subvert the limitations contained within the earlier paragraphs”. His Honour’s reasoning at \[110]–\[120] then explained why the specific treatment and caps in [paragraphs (d) and (e)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) confine stamp duty and mortgage costs to the circumstances and extent those paragraphs permit (Payne JA agreeing at \[1]; Griffiths AJA at \[125]). Those costs cannot be moved into paragraph (f) to avoid those limits.

A special-leave application from part of the judgment was refused with costs by the High Court on 6 June 2024: [_G & J Drivas Pty Ltd v Sydney Metro_ \[2024\] HCASL 162](https://www.hcourt.gov.au/cases-and-judgments/judgments/special-leave-dispositions/g-j-drivas-pty-ltd-acn-002544372-anor-v-sydney-metro-abn-12354063515) . A refusal of special leave is not a decision on the merits of the Court of Appeal’s reasoning. The Court of Appeal’s disturbance ruling addressed replacement-property duty and mortgage costs; it does not determine whether a differently characterised expense satisfies another paragraph.

In [_Dibb v Transport for New South Wales_ \[2024\] NSWCA 157](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/190565ea5177a3d5885e67ed) , an appeal and cross-appeal confined to questions of law, Stern JA (Payne JA agreeing at \[1]; Kirk JA agreeing at \[2]) applied [_Drivas_](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/18d5868626aa8267ce013eb7) . At \[169], her Honour said the earlier approach to compensating the stamp duty under [paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) “was found to be incorrect by this Court in Drivas (CA)”. The Court allowed the cross-appeal and deleted the award: \[168]–\[171]. Special leave to appeal was refused on 7 November 2024: [_Dibb v Transport for NSW_ \[2024\] HCASL 275](https://www.hcourt.gov.au/sites/default/files/eresources/2024/HCASL/275.pdf) .

The case concerned duty on a replacement property which, by common ground, was not purchased for “relocation”. It does not change how [paragraph (d)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) applies where its own conditions are met.

This distinction matters when replacement land is being considered. The claim should identify whether the purchase is for relocation, apply the equivalent-value cap in [paragraph (d)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) , and keep duty and mortgage calculations out of paragraph (f).

## Relocation is not a guarantee of like-for-like premises

In [_Sydney Metro v C & P Automotive Engineers Pty Ltd_ (2024) 115 NSWLR 122; \[2024\] NSWCA 186](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/190341f37d4543d03e71a20d) , Payne JA (Meagher JA agreeing at \[1]; Kirk JA agreeing at \[154]) considered a tenant’s claim under [section 59(1)(c)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) .

At \[93], Payne JA said: “I am prepared to assume, without deciding,” that reasonably incurred setup or fit-out costs may fall within [paragraph (c)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) . That was deliberately not decided. The Court did decide that the provision does not pay for constructing new fixtures belonging to the new landlord merely because comparable fixtures had been available under the acquired lease: \[94]–\[116]. As an additional reason, the lost right to use the former landlord’s fixtures had already been reflected in the market value of the lease: \[124]–\[141]. Additional market rent at replacement premises was not recoverable as disturbance: \[147]–\[152].

The holding is tied to the lease, the ownership of the fixtures and the market-value award in that case. The current [paragraph (c)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) retains the wording considered by the Court. It can extend to the reasonably incurred costs of moving the claimant’s furniture, goods and tenant’s fixtures, and installing those moved items: \[93]. It does not promise premises with the same physical characteristics, establish a general entitlement to setup costs, or transfer to a tenant the cost of replacing property the tenant had no right to move.

## Evidence remains decisive

The appellate principles determine the legal boundaries, but the result in a particular claim depends on proof.

[_The Eddie Arnott Corporation Pty Ltd v Sydney Metro (No 4)_ \[2025\] NSWLEC 103](https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/decision/1993c9b4c823e7f19ae11277) is a first-instance Land and Environment Court compensation decision, not an appellate statement of principle. Pritchard J held that the claim for advice from three different law firms was “excessive” and allowed $10,000 for acquisition-related legal costs at \[211]. Her Honour allowed the $22,000 Sydney Metro had accepted for valuation fees of a qualified valuer reasonably incurred in connection with the compulsory acquisition, under section 59(1)(b), which does not extend to fees calculated by reference to the value, as assessed by the valuer, of the land: \[214]. A wider, general disturbance claim also failed. Her Honour noted at \[198] that the claimant had neither identified the paragraph of [section 59(1)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) on which it relied nor quantified the claim, and disallowed it at \[204] as unsubstantiated and unquantified.

A first-instance decision can be varied or set aside on appeal, so a reader should check its status before relying on it. As at 20 November 2026, NSW Caselaw had published no Court of Appeal judgment in this matter. That publication check does not establish whether an appeal was filed or its current status, which remains unverified here. The decision is used only to illustrate proof and reasonableness; the Court of Appeal authorities above remain controlling.

## Building a disturbance schedule

The claimant should prepare the schedule while costs are being considered, not after they have been incurred. It should include:

| Field                 | Purpose                                                             |
| --------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Item                  | describe the cost precisely                                         |
| Claimant              | identify the person or entity that incurred it                      |
| Disturbance paragraph | state the statutory category relied on                              |
| Amount                | separate paid, committed and estimated amounts                      |
| Date                  | show when the cost arose or is expected                             |
| Actual use            | explain how the item relates to the actual use of the acquired land |
| Causal link           | explain why it results from the acquisition                         |
| Reasonableness        | record alternatives, quotes and mitigation                          |
| Evidence              | link invoices, reports, contracts and payment records               |
| Overlap check         | identify any related market-value, reinstatement or other claim     |

For a business relocation, the supporting file may include the lease, asset register, premises plans, relocation and temporary-site quotes, replacement-site searches, fit-out scopes, trading records and a chronology of operational decisions. For a residential or investment property, it may include removal and storage invoices, replacement-property searches, duty calculations, mortgage documents and evidence of the equivalent-value cap.

The schedule should expose, rather than conceal, the common weaknesses in a disturbance claim:

- relying on [paragraph (f)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) as a catch-all;
- claiming lost revenue without a qualifying financial cost;
- duplicating market value or reinstatement; and
- presenting a lump sum without proof of amount, cause and reasonableness.

Reinstatement and disturbance can overlap. [Section 56(3)](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.56) applies where the land is used for a particular purpose, there is no general market for land used for that purpose, and the owner genuinely proposes to continue using other land for that purpose after the acquisition. Market value is then taken to be the reasonable cost to the owner of equivalent reinstatement in some other location, and that cost “is to be reduced by any costs for which compensation is payable for loss attributable to disturbance and by any likely improvement in the owner’s financial position because of the relocation”.

Acquisition-related professional costs should also remain separate from the costs of Court proceedings. A Court objection requires funding and can produce a lower compensation award, unrecovered expenditure or an adverse costs order. For the Class 3 costs principles and the Court’s separate power to reduce interest, see [Class 3 proceeding costs and the costs consequences of an objection](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/just-terms-act-cost-recovery/) .

## A government review of the Act is under way

The NSW Government, led by the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure, is reviewing the _Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991_ (NSW) and the whole-of-government approach to property acquisition. Public consultation on a discussion paper closed on 3 May 2024. The Department’s [land acquisition review page](https://www.planning.nsw.gov.au/the-planning-system/under-review-and-new-policy-and-legislation/land-acquisition-review) , last updated on 19 November 2025, says final recommendations are expected to be considered by Government in 2026.

A review is not a change in the law. As at 20 November 2026, the Act had not been amended since 5 July 2024, and [section 59](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/whole/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022#sec.59) reads as set out above. Any change to the disturbance categories would need amending legislation, so a reader should check the current version of the Act before relying on this summary.

For the wider framework, see [just terms compensation in NSW](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/just-terms-compensation-basics/) , our overview of [land acquisition and compensation](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/land-acquisition/) and our [compulsory acquisition practice](https://stonepillar.com.au/services/compulsory-acquisition/) . For legal costs and some valuation fees, see the article on [costs in compulsory acquisition](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/just-terms-act-cost-recovery/) .

The firm’s [land acquisition tool](https://stonepillar.com.au/navigator/tools/land-acquisition/) helps prepare an acquisition, access or project-impact enquiry for preliminary review. It does not assess entitlement, compensation, deadlines or an offer.

This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.

![Michael Themis](https://stonepillar.com.au/michael-themis-author.jpg)

Author

[Michael Themis](https://stonepillar.com.au/about/)

Principal Solicitor · Stone & Pillar Legal

Michael brings experience of both private practice and government to planning, environmental regulation and compulsory acquisition. Trained at Herbert Smith Freehills and King & Wood Mallesons, he has senior in-house experience across the Commonwealth and New South Wales governments.

[(02) 8014 5817 ](tel:+61280145817)[michael@stonepillar.com.au ](mailto:michael@stonepillar.com.au)Level 13, 111 Elizabeth Street\
Sydney NSW 2000

[LinkedIn ](https://www.linkedin.com/in/michaelthemis)[Save contact card (vCard)](https://stonepillar.com.au/michael-themis.vcf)

## Legislation on this page

- [_Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991_ (NSW) ](https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/html/inforce/current/act-1991-022)ss 55, 56, 59, 60, 61 Official text read 29 September 2026; version in force from 5 July 2024.

## Related insights

- [Compulsory acquisition — Choosing a lawyer for a compulsory acquisition claim in NSW](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/choosing-a-compulsory-acquisition-lawyer-nsw/)
- [Compulsory acquisition — Disadvantage resulting from relocation in NSW acquisitions](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/disadvantage-resulting-from-relocation-nsw/)
- [Compulsory acquisition — Legal and valuation costs in NSW compulsory acquisition](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/just-terms-act-cost-recovery/)

## Related situations

- [Compulsory acquisition — Compulsory acquisition of land in NSW](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/land-acquisition/)
- [Compulsory acquisition — Proposed Acquisition Notices in NSW](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/proposed-acquisition-notice/)
- [Compulsory acquisition — Land affected by NSW infrastructure projects](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/affected-by-project/)
- [Compulsory acquisition — Partial acquisitions and retained land in NSW](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/partial-acquisitions/)
- [Compulsory acquisition — Business relocation after acquisition in NSW](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/business-relocation/)
- [Compulsory acquisition — Acquisition valuation evidence in NSW](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/acquisition-valuation/)
- [Compulsory acquisition — Compensation objections in NSW](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/compensation-objections/)

This article sits within our [Compulsory acquisition and compensation ](https://stonepillar.com.au/services/compulsory-acquisition/)practice.

[All insights](https://stonepillar.com.au/insights/)

Your matter

## Business or relocation losses to address?

Tell us how the acquisition affects your operations and the stage of the compensation process.

[How we help with disturbance claims](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/land-acquisition/)

[Speak with a lawyer](https://stonepillar.com.au/contact/?matter=acquisition&timing=deadline&issue=land-acquisition#schedule)

30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge

The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake.

---

The information and tools on this website are general information only and are not legal advice. Please provide only a brief outline for an initial enquiry, and keep confidential or privileged documents to hand until we tell you how to provide them. Tell us any date stated in your documents. Do not assume that an enquiry or booking protects a deadline. Ask us to confirm any work we agree to undertake, including any action about a deadline. If a date is close or uncertain, seek prompt legal advice without waiting for our reply. See the full [Disclaimer](https://stonepillar.com.au/disclaimer/) and [collection notice](https://stonepillar.com.au/privacy/#collection-notice) .

© 2026 Stone & Pillar Legal · New South Wales

Stone & Pillar Legal is a business name of Stone & Pillar Pty Ltd ABN 11 698 040 854.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation.
