Skip to content

Land access and easements

NSW transmission easements: refusing an agreement and protecting landowner rights

Published
8 October 2026
By
Michael Themis, Principal Solicitor
Jurisdiction
New South Wales

NSW transmission easements: refusing an agreement, challenging acquisition, protecting retained land and separating compensation from benefit payments.

High-voltage transmission towers and power lines crossing open land
On this page

NSW transmission easements, negotiation and landowner rights

A landowner can refuse to sign a proposed transmission-easement agreement. But that refusal does not prevent an authority with the necessary legal power from compulsorily acquiring the easement.

The first steps are to identify who proposes to acquire it, check their legal power and the acquisition process, and understand the rights the easement would give them. Those rights also matter when assessing the owner’s loss and compensation.

The project’s planning approval, the lawfulness of the acquisition and the amount of compensation are separate questions. Disputing the price does not itself stop acquisition. Opposing the route does not, by itself, show that the authority lacks power.

Check who has power to acquire

The Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 (NSW), or Just Terms Act, sets the acquisition framework. Under section 7, the Act does not give an authority power to acquire land that it otherwise lacks.

For transmission projects, the acquiring entity matters. A network operator (a transmission operator or a distributor) has power to acquire land for its functions under section 44 of the Electricity Supply Act 1995 (NSW). Under section 44(3), it may not give a proposed acquisition notice without the Minister’s approval. The Energy Corporation of New South Wales, which operates as EnergyCo, has a separate power under section 15 of the Energy and Utilities Administration Act 1987 (NSW), for the purposes of that Act or any other Act administered by its Minister.

Identify the legal entity named in the documents, the purpose for which the law allows it to acquire land, and exactly what land or rights it proposes to acquire. A project name or a contractor’s letter does not establish those matters. Private ownership does not by itself exclude statutory acquisition power: the definition of a transmission operator extends to a person who owns, controls or operates a transmission system. Lines are a transmission system only where an order under section 93 of the Electricity Supply Act makes them one. Check the entity’s statutory power and every condition on its exercise.

An easement gives rights over land; it does not necessarily transfer ownership of the land itself. Read the plan and terms together. Check permanent transmission rights, construction access and temporary occupation separately.

Rejecting an offer is different from refusing to negotiate

Unless an exception applies, section 10A requires the authority to make a genuine attempt to acquire the land by agreement for at least six months before giving a proposed acquisition notice. The parties can agree to a shorter or longer period. The Minister can also approve a shorter period if the statutory conditions are met.

Under section 10A(6), the authority need not comply with that section if the owner notifies it that the owner is not prepared to negotiate, or if the owner cannot be located after reasonable inquiries. Rejecting particular terms is not the same as notifying the authority that the owner will not negotiate. Correspondence should accurately record the owner’s position.

Section 10A(1) excludes Crown land, an easement or right to use land under the surface for works, and a stratum under the surface for a tunnel. The underground-easement exclusion is not a general exclusion for overhead transmission easements. Section 10A(7) provides that nothing in the section “gives rise to, or can be taken into account in, any civil cause of action”.

In Perry Properties Pty Limited v Georges River Council [2023] NSWLEC 51, the Land and Environment Court found that the council had met section 10A by negotiating with the owner for six months, and need not negotiate with every holder of an interest in the land ([150]). The Court added that, even if section 10A had not been complied with, it did not consider that this would affect the lawfulness of issuing the proposed acquisition notices ([152]). It also found that section 10A(7) prevented section 10A from being relied on in civil enforcement proceedings brought under section 674 of the Local Government Act 1993 (NSW) ([153]). This is a single first-instance decision, so a complaint about negotiations does not, of itself, give grounds to stop an acquisition.

Check notices and challenge rights

A proposed acquisition notice, commonly called a PAN, announces an intention to acquire. It does not itself transfer the interest to the authority. Under section 13, it generally must be given at least 90 days before acquisition. A shorter period requires either the written agreement of the authority and the owners, or approval by the Minister responsible for the authority on the ground that urgency or other circumstances make a longer period impracticable. That approval needs the concurrence of the Minister administering the Act (section 13(3)). This is a minimum notice period, not a universal deadline for court proceedings. If the land is not acquired within 120 days after the notice is given, or a longer period agreed in writing, the notice is taken to have been withdrawn (section 14). Under section 19, the authority, with the Governor’s approval, declares the acquisition by a notice published in the Gazette. On the date of that publication, section 20 vests the land in the authority and frees it of other interests, subject to section 20(1A).

A legal challenge must identify what is legally wrong with the authority’s power or the acquisition process and use the correct court procedure. If an interim court order may be needed, consider it promptly.

Section 33 provides that, once land has been compulsorily acquired, its validity is not affected by a failure to comply with Part 2 requirements about giving notice of the proposed acquisition, or by a subsequent failure to comply with a requirement of the Act relating to the acquisition. Whether there is a separate defect in acquisition power requires its own analysis.

Continuing discussions do not themselves suspend the process. Proceedings can fail, involve substantial legal costs and leave the owner liable for the other party’s costs.

Compensation follows a different route. A person who has claimed compensation under Part 3 can generally object to the amount in the Land and Environment Court. Under section 66, the ordinary deadline is 90 days after receiving a compensation notice. An amended compensation notice can change the day from which those 90 days run (section 43A(5)–(6)), so count from the notice that applies. If the person neither accepts the offer nor objects within those 90 days, the offer is taken to have been accepted under section 45. That acceptance remains subject to the Court’s decision on any late objection (section 45(2)). A late objection may still be lodged, but the Court cannot hear and determine the claim unless satisfied there was good cause for missing the period: section 66(3). The Court determines the compensation claim, not a general appeal against the transmission route. A higher result is not assured.

Assess the easement and compensation

A corridor’s area is only the starting point. Assess how the transmission easement affects the property’s use:

  • tower locations, access tracks and machinery movements;
  • cropping, irrigation, livestock movement and biosecurity;
  • restrictions on buildings, vegetation and future land use;
  • construction damage, reinstatement and continuing maintenance access; and
  • effects on the use and value of retained land.

These effects do not automatically create an entitlement to compensation. Maps, farm records, photographs and a valuer’s assessment should explain how the rights being acquired affect the property. Each claimed loss must also fit within a category of compensation allowed by the Act.

Section 55 lists the only matters to which regard is had in determining compensation: market value, special value, severance, disturbance, disadvantage resulting from relocation, and any increase or decrease in the value of the owner’s adjoining or severed land. An increase in the value of retained land can reduce compensation. Different labels cannot justify recovering the same loss twice. The compensation framework explains those distinctions.

Before signing, record the agreed access conditions, works, costs, payment dates and any claims that remain unresolved. Check any release clause carefully: it may give up claims beyond the agreed easement price. For an agreed acquisition of land not available for public sale, section 38 requires the authority to take the statutory compensation matters into account. The agreement still needs careful drafting.

Keep benefit payments separate

Strategic benefit payments are not a substitute for statutory compensation. An entitlement to those payments must be disregarded when determining compensation under Part 3 of the Just Terms Act. Section 44(4) of the Electricity Supply Act and section 15(4) of the Energy and Utilities Administration Act require that separation.

Eligibility and payment terms depend on the applicable licence condition and guidelines. List each proposed payment separately, including its legal basis and any conditions attached to it. A single total can hide differences between compensation and benefit payments.

Frequently asked questions

Does refusing the easement prevent survey access?

Not necessarily. Network operators have separate statutory entry powers, subject to conditions, under Part 5, Division 3 (sections 54–63A) of the Electricity Supply Act. Those conditions include entry during daylight hours except in an emergency (section 54(2)), written notice in most cases (section 55) and no entry to the residential part of a building without the occupier’s consent or a warrant, except to read a meter (section 62). Check which entry power the operator relies on, what notice is required and whether the person seeking entry is authorised. EnergyCo has separate entry powers under section 39 of the Energy and Utilities Administration Act 1987 (NSW). Survey entry under section 39(2)(a) requires written authorisation and excludes dwelling-places. Section 39(2)(b) is broader: it allows entry by the Corporation’s employees or agents, or by Department officers, to do what is required for purposes connected with its functions, without those two limits. Either power requires at least seven days’ notice to the owner or occupier. Section 39 also limits damage to what is necessary and requires full compensation for damage sustained in exercising the power.

What should an owner assemble first?

The title, proposed easement plan and terms, correspondence, notices and a description of how the property is used and managed. At a preliminary enquiry, describe the issue and any deadline. Confidential documents should await written confirmation that the firm can act.

This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.

Michael Themis

Author

Michael Themis

Principal Solicitor · Stone & Pillar Legal

Michael brings experience of both private practice and government to planning, environmental regulation and compulsory acquisition. Trained at Herbert Smith Freehills and King & Wood Mallesons, he has senior in-house experience across the Commonwealth and New South Wales governments.

(02) 8014 5817 michael@stonepillar.com.au Level 13, 111 Elizabeth Street
Sydney NSW 2000

Legislation on this page

Your matter

Discuss an energy project affecting your land

Start with the project, the proposed use of your land and your priorities. On a short preliminary call we can tell you whether we can assist and what the first step would be.

How we help with transmission easements

Speak with a lawyer

30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge

The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake.

Speak with a lawyer Call