Objecting to a NSW land value: preparing before the notice arrives
- 21 November 2026
- Michael Themis, Principal Solicitor
- New South Wales
How to object to a NSW land value: checking the deadline, choosing the right ground, preparing evidence and assessing the costs of a court appeal.
On this page
- January notices: distinguish the documents
- Challenging the right decision
- Identify the valuation date and the error
- Checking the objection deadline and any earlier objection
- Preparing the evidence before lodging
- The review and its consequences
- Weighing a court appeal against its cost
- Frequently asked questions
A NSW land value objection asks the Valuer General to correct a valuation used for land tax or council rates. The objector should start by checking the deadline, identifying the error and gathering evidence, and should prepare before the notice arrives where possible: the Valuer General’s guidance requires the evidence relied on when the objector lodges.
A large increase, an unaffordable bill or a neighbour’s lower value does not, by itself, prove an error.
January notices: distinguish the documents
Revenue NSW starts issuing land tax assessments from January each year. That does not mean every owner receives a Valuer General notice each January.
Land values are generally determined annually. Councils receive new values for rating at least every three years. The Valuer General sends valuation notices when those values are supplied; supplementary notices can arise separately. The landowner should check the property’s notices and valuation history when preparing in November.
Challenging the right decision
A challenge to the land value is made by objection under the Valuation of Land Act 1916 (NSW). Land tax exemption or liability issues go to Revenue NSW through its separate processes. Council rating categories and calculations also need separate attention.
A valuation objection does not resolve an exemption claim or challenge compulsory-acquisition compensation. The firm’s valuation and compensation objections guide explains the different pathways.
Identify the valuation date and the error
Section 6A sets the legal assumptions for land value. These generally exclude buildings but retain certain land improvements. Under section 14B, a general valuation assesses the land as at 1 July in the relevant valuing year.
An estimate of today’s house-and-land price is therefore not the required comparison. Sales need adjustments for buildings, site differences and market movement to that 1 July. Land tax commonly uses an average of three annual values, where applicable. The objector should identify which underlying valuation is disputed.
Section 34 allows grounds including a value that is too high or low, incorrect area or description, incorrect apportionment, and land wrongly valued together or separately. It also covers a wrongly named owner or lessee. The objector should match the evidence to the ground. When challenging the amount, the objector should explain the proposed value and how the evidence supports it.
An objector to a notice of valuation must also notify each other person to whom notice of that valuation is required to be given under section 29(1) that the objection has been made and of the reasons for it (section 29(3B)).
Checking the objection deadline and any earlier objection
Section 35 ordinarily requires an objection within 60 days after service of the valuation notice or relevant land tax assessment. Official guidance points to the notice’s deadline or assessment issue date. The objector should record both, keep delivery evidence and resolve service questions promptly. Reading a notice later does not necessarily extend time. Late permission under section 35A is discretionary.
A tax reassessment does not necessarily restart the objection period. Section 35(2) requires a changed land value, allowance or apportionment factor for the parcel concerned.
The objector should also check whether the same valuation has already been objected to. Under section 35AA, another objection to that land tax valuation requires the Valuer General’s permission for special reasons, even within 60 days.
Preparing the evidence before lodging
For a value said to be too high or low, the Valuer General’s evidence guidance calls for a proposed value, supporting reasons and three comparable sales. If the objector uses the property’s own sale, additional sales are optional. An objector should not assume an incomplete objection can be lodged and the evidence built later.
The objector should gather material relevant to the grounds:
- the notice, property identifiers and relevant valuation year;
- for an amount challenge, the valuation sales and benchmark reports, with sale dates, prices and explanations of differences;
- plans, photographs or planning material supporting each alleged error.
An independent valuation may help with disputed adjustments or development assumptions. The objector should give the valuer the legal test and valuation date.
The review and its consequences
The published review process uses a different valuer. After a preliminary report, the objector has 14 days to request a conference about questions, unaddressed points from the original submission or substantive factual errors. This is not a general opportunity to rebuild the evidence.
The value may stay unchanged or fall. Evidence of undervaluation can also prompt a separate review and an increase. Under section 36, rates and taxes remain payable during an objection or appeal.
Weighing a court appeal against its cost
Following an adverse determination, sections 37–40 provide a Class 3 appeal to the Land and Environment Court (section 19(b) of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW)). The ordinary deadline is 60 days after issue of the determination notice. The appellant must prove the case.
If no determination notice is given within 90 days after lodging, the objection is treated as disallowed for appeal purposes. An appeal on that basis may not be made unless the objector has given the Valuer General at least 14 days’ written notice of the intention to appeal on that ground. Under section 39, the appellant’s and respondent’s cases on an appeal are not limited to the grounds of the objection; Court directions govern expert evidence.
The objector should compare legal, valuation and court costs with the disputed tax or rates. Under rule 3.7 of the Land and Environment Court Rules 2007 (NSW), the Court is not to make a costs order unless it considers the order fair and reasonable in the circumstances. Winning does not guarantee costs recovery; unreasonable conduct can expose the objector to adverse costs. A first conversation with the firm can establish which notice applies, its dates and what is in dispute before substantial expenditure. It does not engage the firm, and advice on the objection follows only once the firm is engaged and has the documents.
General information, current as at 20 November 2026. Individual notices and circumstances require separate advice.
Frequently asked questions
Does a large valuation increase justify an objection?
It justifies investigation. To challenge the amount, the objector's evidence must support a statutory ground and the appropriate value at the relevant date. Dissatisfaction alone is insufficient.
Can a land tax exemption be obtained through a valuation objection?
No. The landowner should take exemption and liability issues through Revenue NSW's separate processes. They have their own requirements and deadlines.
This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.
Principal Solicitor · Stone & Pillar Legal
Michael brings experience of both private practice and government to planning, environmental regulation and compulsory acquisition. Trained at Herbert Smith Freehills and King & Wood Mallesons, he has senior in-house experience across the Commonwealth and New South Wales governments.
(02) 8014 5817 michael@stonepillar.com.au Level 13, 111 Elizabeth StreetSydney NSW 2000
Legislation on this page
- act-1916-002 ss 6A, 35, 35AA, 37, 39 Official text read 29 September 2026; version in force from 4 September 2023.
- act-1956-026 s 9AA Official text read 29 September 2026; version in force from 10 June 2026.
- sl-2007-0578 r 3.7 Official text read 29 September 2026; version in force from 15 May 2020.
Related insights
This article sits within our Compulsory acquisition and compensation practice.