---
title: "NSW valuation and compensation objections"
description: "How NSW compensation objections and land-valuation appeals differ, including their respective Class 3 pathways and time-limit issues."
canonical: https://stonepillar.com.au/valuation-and-compensation-objections/
language: en-AU
last_updated: 2026-10-16
source_revision: 498ccea127247fe38494c2df5ab784af20b5625f
publisher: "Stone & Pillar Legal"
---

Land and Environment Court · Class 3

# Valuation and compensation objections

Three different disputes are often spoken of as one. Objecting to the amount of compensation after a compulsory acquisition, objecting to a land valuation used for land tax and rates, and challenging an acquisition itself are separate matters, with different forums, tests and time limits. Identifying the right process early helps you check which steps and deadlines apply.

- Jurisdiction

  New South Wales

- Forum

  Land and Environment Court, Class 3

- Page type

  Explainer

Three disputes, three paths

## First, identify the dispute you are actually in

Each of the following has its own forum and its own clock, and a step taken in one does not preserve your rights in another. The distinction matters most at the start, when the deadlines are running.

01 The acquisition itself

### Whether the land should have been acquired, or the process was lawful

If the question is the validity of the acquisition, that is a challenge to the decision, generally pursued by judicial review in the Supreme Court on limited legal grounds. It is separate from compensation. Proceedings generally must begin within three months of the decision, subject to applicable exceptions and any extension granted by the Court. Obtain advice promptly: steps may be needed before acquisition takes effect. The source of the challenged function determines the available jurisdiction.

Generally Supreme Court; LEC Class 4 where its statutory jurisdiction applies

02 The amount of compensation

### The acquisition stands, but the compensation offered is too low

Compensation for a compulsory acquisition is assessed under the _Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991_. A person who has claimed compensation may generally object to the amount offered in the Land and Environment Court within 90 days after receiving the compensation notice. If the person neither accepts nor objects within that period, the offer is generally taken to be accepted. A late objection requires good cause under section 66(3).

Land and Environment Court, Class 3

03 A land valuation

### The Valuer-General's land value used for land tax or council rates

Where the concern is the land value itself (not a compulsory acquisition), that is a valuation objection under the _Valuation of Land Act 1916_: object to the Valuer-General first, and if still dissatisfied, appeal to the Land and Environment Court in Class 3, generally within 60 days after the date of issue of the notice of determination.

Land and Environment Court, Class 3

These time limits are indicative only and can turn on the facts and on the terms of the notice you have received. The safe course is to confirm the deadline that applies to your matter as soon as a notice arrives, rather than rely on a general period.

Compulsory acquisition

## Objecting to the amount of compensation

Compensation for land acquired by a NSW authority is assessed on just terms under the _Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991_. The process runs to a sequence of notices and deadlines, and the point at which you can object to the Land and Environment Court is a specific one, tied to the compensation notice, not to the earlier notice of the proposed acquisition.

1. Early engagement

   Section 10A generally requires a genuine attempt to acquire by agreement for at least six months before a proposed acquisition notice, subject to an agreed shorter or longer period and statutory exceptions. For an agreed acquisition of land not available for public sale, section 38 requires the authority to take into account the same matters as on compulsory acquisition. The agreed terms still matter.

2. Proposed acquisition notice

   A proposed acquisition notice (s 11) signals the intention to acquire and generally must run for at least 90 days before the land can be acquired (s 13). The notice will also ask you to lodge a claim for compensation within a stated period, which must be at least 60 days after the notice is given (ss 15(e) and 39). That claim is your first statement of what you say the compensation should be, so it is worth getting right, and only a person who has claimed compensation can later object to the amount offered (s 66(1)). Responding to the notice does not, however, start the period for objecting to the amount of compensation; that period runs from the later compensation notice (s 66).

3. Acquisition

   The acquisition takes legal effect on publication in the Government Gazette. The Valuer-General determines the compensation to be offered before or after acquisition. The authority generally must give the required compensation notice within 45 days after publication. The Minister may extend that period by up to 60 days where necessary for valuation; competing claims to interests may also permit delay (section 42).

4. Objection to the LEC

   A person who has claimed compensation may generally object to the Land and Environment Court in Class 3 within 90 days after receiving the compensation notice. If a person entitled to compensation neither accepts nor objects in time, the offer is generally taken to be accepted. The Court may hear a late objection only if satisfied there is good cause for the failure to lodge in time (sections 45 and 66). An amended notice can change the operative receipt date under section 43A. The Court can determine more or less compensation than the offer. It may cancel or reduce interest accruing after proceedings begin if compensation, excluding interest, does not exceed the offer by more than 10%. Court costs are a separate risk.

### The heads of compensation

Compensation may include more than market value. Special rules apply to hardship acquisitions and some subsurface acquisitions. For a hardship acquisition, section 26 allows special value, severance, disturbance and relocation disadvantage to be left out of account. Subject to the applicable rules, compensation can include:

- special value
- loss attributable to severance, and separately, increases or decreases in the value of adjoining or severed retained land caused by the public purpose or its proposal (section 55(f))
- loss attributable to disturbance (which can extend to legal costs, some valuation fees of a qualified valuer and the costs of relocating a home or business)
- for a principal place of residence, disadvantage resulting from relocation (formerly called solatium)

Market value is assessed disregarding any change in value caused by the public purpose of the acquisition (s 56(1)(a)).

Related: [land acquisition & compensation ](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/land-acquisition/)· [proposed acquisition notices ](https://stonepillar.com.au/issues/proposed-acquisition-notice/)· [how we act on acquisitions](https://stonepillar.com.au/services/compulsory-acquisition/)

Survey & Section: a corridor taken through rural holdings, and the remnants it leaves behind.

Land tax & council rates

## Objecting to a land valuation

A separate objection concerns the land value determined by the Valuer-General. That value underpins **land tax** (_Land Tax Management Act 1956_) and **council rates** (_Local Government Act 1993_), so an inflated value has a recurring cost. This is not a compulsory acquisition matter, and it follows the _Valuation of Land Act 1916_.

- **Object to the Valuer-General first.** An objection to the land value is generally made within 60 days after service of the valuation notice, or service of the land-tax assessment for a land-tax valuation, setting out the grounds. The Valuer-General can allow a late objection. Liability to pay rates or land tax continues while the dispute proceeds.
- **Then appeal to the Land and Environment Court.** An eligible person dissatisfied with the determination may generally appeal in Class 3 within 60 days after the date of issue of its notice (section 37). The Court may allow a late appeal, but that should not be relied on. If notice of the determination has not been given within 90 days after lodgement, the objection is taken to be disallowed for appeal purposes; an appeal on that basis requires at least 14 days' written notice to the Valuer-General.
- **Evidence decides it.** As with compensation, the result turns on valuation evidence, comparable sales and the assumptions applied, so the grounds and the material behind them matter from the outset.

How we help

## Identify the dispute, protect the deadline, then build the case

We advise landowners and businesses affected by compulsory acquisition on the acquisition process, compensation and related disputes, and property owners on valuation objections. On a compensation or valuation matter that usually means:

- confirming which objection pathway applies and the date by which any objection must be made
- assessing an offer or valuation against the proper statutory basis
- briefing and leading valuation and other expert evidence
- where a matter does not resolve, conducting the Class 3 proceedings

Much of the early work is offered in defined, fixed-scope steps, so you can begin without committing to an open retainer.

This page is general information about New South Wales law only. It is not legal advice, does not take account of your circumstances, and time limits and entitlements depend on the facts and on the terms of any notice you have received. Reading it, or making an enquiry, does not create a solicitor–client relationship. Obtain legal advice about your own circumstances, and do so promptly where a deadline may be running.

Your next step

## Discuss valuation or compensation

Tell us which valuation, decision or amount you dispute and when you received it. A preliminary call helps establish whether we can assist; it does not confirm a legal deadline or constitute advice.

[Request a call back](https://stonepillar.com.au/contact/?matter=acquisition#enquiry)

[Speak with a lawyer](https://stonepillar.com.au/contact/?matter=acquisition#schedule)

30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge

The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake.

---

The information and tools on this website are general information only and are not legal advice. Please provide only a brief outline for an initial enquiry, and keep confidential or privileged documents to hand until we tell you how to provide them. Tell us any date stated in your documents. Do not assume that an enquiry or booking protects a deadline. Ask us to confirm any work we agree to undertake, including any action about a deadline. If a date is close or uncertain, seek prompt legal advice without waiting for our reply. See the full [Disclaimer](https://stonepillar.com.au/disclaimer/) and [collection notice](https://stonepillar.com.au/privacy/#collection-notice) .

© 2026 Stone & Pillar Legal · New South Wales

Stone & Pillar Legal is a business name of Stone & Pillar Pty Ltd ABN 11 698 040 854.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation.
