Council has not determined my application
Where a council does not determine a development application within the statutory assessment period, the application may be treated as a 'deemed refusal'. That gives you the option to appeal to the Land and Environment Court even though no formal decision has been made.
- New South Wales
- Issue overview
- Time-sensitive
On this page
This page may be relevant if:
- Your DA has been with council for an extended period without a decision
- Council keeps requesting further information and the assessment has stalled
- You need to understand when the assessment period actually expires
- You want to move the application forward without losing goodwill with council
What this usually means
- The assessment period depends on the application and the statutory pauses and adjustments. A section 36 information request stops the clock under section 94(2) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2021 only if made within 25 days after lodgement. Other statutory adjustments, including further time allowed to provide requested information and the effect of amendments, must be checked separately; an informal agreement does not itself stop time.
- Once the period has elapsed without a determination, the application is taken to have been refused for appeal purposes. Since 21 March 2026 that appeal can be commenced at any time until the application is actually determined, rather than within a fixed window.
- A deemed-refusal appeal can run in parallel with continued assessment and discussions with council. A later determination does not by itself end an appeal already commenced; the effect of the decision on the existing proceedings needs separate advice.
What commonly matters
-
When the clock expires
Calculating the assessment period, including 'stop the clock' provisions, determines when an appeal right arises.
-
Strategy with council
An appeal does not have to be adversarial. It can be a way to bring structure and a timetable to a stalled assessment.
-
Readiness of the application
If outstanding information is the real issue, addressing it early improves both the council process and any appeal.
How we help
- Calculate the assessment period and confirm whether a deemed refusal has arisen
- Advise on whether to appeal, escalate or continue with council
- Manage the appeal and conciliation process if commenced
- Coordinate the further information and evidence council requires
This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.
Frequently asked questions
General information only, not legal advice. The position depends on your circumstances.
How long does a council have to determine a development application in NSW before it is a deemed refusal?
Under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 and the Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2021, a consent authority is generally given a set number of days to determine a development application before it is taken to have been refused. This period is commonly 40 days for a standard local application, and longer (such as 60 days) for designated, integrated or concurrence development, or 90 days for State significant development. The exact period that applies, and how the days are counted, depends on the type of application and whether the clock has been paused, so the position should be checked against the specific facts.
How long do I have to appeal a deemed refusal to the Land and Environment Court?
Since 21 March 2026, an eligible deemed-refusal appeal can be commenced after the statutory assessment period ends and before the application is determined. Section 4.55(1) modification applications are excluded from Part 8 review and appeal rights. If the consent authority decides an eligible application before an appeal is commenced, any merits appeal must instead address the actual decision and its applicable time limit. A later decision does not by itself end an appeal already commenced. The Department's published position is that eligible applications still undetermined may be appealed even if the former deemed-refusal appeal period expired. Earlier rules remain for reviews or appeals lodged but not finally determined before 21 March 2026, so the application history matters. Separately, for section 4.55(1) applications subject to the new provisions, the 14-day rule imposes a determination duty; it creates neither deemed approval nor a Part 8 merits appeal, and refusal remains required where the statutory housing and productivity contribution exception applies. Transitional rules and the assessment history should be checked before relying on either pathway.
Can the council still approve my DA after the assessment period has expired or after I lodge a deemed refusal appeal?
Generally yes. A deemed refusal does not formally decide your application, so the council can usually still grant consent while the assessment continues, and lodging an appeal does not by itself stop those discussions. In practice a deemed refusal appeal often runs in parallel with council assessment, and many matters resolve by the council or the Court approving the application before a contested hearing. Whether to appeal, keep working with the council, or do both depends on the circumstances of the application.
What kind of court process is a deemed refusal appeal, and is it always adversarial?
A deemed refusal appeal is generally a Class 1 merits appeal in the Land and Environment Court, where the Court re-considers the application and can decide to grant or refuse consent. These appeals are commonly referred to a conciliation conference under the Land and Environment Court Act 1979, which gives the parties a structured opportunity to reach agreement before any hearing. As a result the process is not necessarily adversarial and is often used to bring a timetable and structure to a stalled assessment, though outcomes depend on the merits of the proposal and the facts.
Related situations
- Planning & development My DA was refused Understand your appeal options, evidence needs, deadlines and the Land and Environment Court pathway.
- Planning & development I need approval for a project Assess approval pathways, environmental issues, planning controls, agency decisions and approval risk.
- Planning & development I need planning due diligence Identify planning controls, approval pathways, constraints, environmental risks and feasibility before committing.
Where to start
No decision on your DA yet?
Tell us when the application was lodged and what has happened since. On a short preliminary call we can tell you whether we can assist and what the first step would be.
30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge
The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake. Tell us any date stated in the documents. Do not assume that sending an enquiry or making a booking protects a deadline. Ask us to confirm the work we have agreed to undertake, including any action about a deadline. If a date is close or uncertain, seek prompt legal advice rather than waiting for an online reply.