Skip to content
Environment & pollution

I am facing environmental enforcement or prosecution

Environmental enforcement in New South Wales escalates quickly: an incident or complaint becomes an investigation, an investigation produces compulsory notices and interviews, and the outcome can be a penalty notice, an enforceable undertaking or prosecution. The decisions made in the first days, what is said, what is produced and how, often shape the entire matter.

Jurisdiction
New South Wales
Page type
Issue overview
Timing
Time-sensitive
On this page

This page may be relevant if:

  • You or your company are under investigation by the EPA, council or another regulator
  • You have received a compulsory information notice or an interview request
  • You have been issued a penalty notice and are deciding how to respond
  • You have been charged, or told that prosecution is being considered

What this usually means

  • Regulators hold broad investigation powers under the Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997, including notices compelling information and records; responding to them is mandatory, and responses need care because they form part of the record.
  • Many environmental offences are strict liability, so intention is not required; the more serious tiers involve wilful or negligent conduct and substantially higher penalties.
  • Paying a penalty notice in full generally prevents further proceedings for the alleged offence, subject to the withdrawal and court-election provisions. Separate offences and other preserved liabilities may remain, so the notice, facts and available options should be reviewed before payment.
  • Under the Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997, offences other than Tier 1 offences may be prosecuted summarily in the Local Court or Land and Environment Court. Tier 1 proceedings may be heard summarily in the Land and Environment Court or on indictment in the Supreme Court. The offence and statute determine the pathway; directors and managers may face personal liability under particular provisions.

What commonly matters

  1. The first response

    Early admissions, informal explanations and incomplete productions all carry consequences. Getting advice before responding preserves options.

  2. Penalty notice or defence

    Whether to pay, elect to contest or engage with the regulator about alternatives depends on the evidence and the exposure.

  3. Enforceable undertakings

    For some matters an enforceable undertaking may resolve enforcement without conviction, but acceptance is discretionary. EPA guidelines ordinarily require a proposal within one month after the alleged breach or issue and negotiations to end within six months after it, with exceptional departures. These are policy timeframes. Responsibility or admission expectations, publication and continuing investigation should be considered before a proposal is made.

  4. Sentencing and mitigation

    Where prosecution proceeds, the work done on remediation, systems and cooperation before sentence materially affects the outcome.

How we help

  • Advise immediately on investigation responses, interviews and notices
  • Deal with the regulator on your behalf
  • Advise on penalty notices, representations and enforceable undertakings
  • Defend prosecutions and act on sentence in the Land and Environment Court

This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.

Frequently asked questions

General information only, not legal advice. The position depends on your circumstances.

Do I have to answer an EPA notice requiring information or records?

Generally yes. Statutory notices under the Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997 (NSW) are compulsory, and self-incrimination does not excuse compliance. A natural person has a qualified protection against direct use of compelled information or answers in criminal proceedings if they object on self-incrimination grounds when providing them, or are not warned on that occasion that they may object. The protection does not extend to proceedings for offences under Chapter 7, such as false or misleading answers. Pre-existing records and evidence obtained as a result of the information or answers are treated differently, and the protection does not apply to corporations. Legal professional privilege may apply to particular material. Obtain advice about the notice, warnings, privilege and response before the due date.

Should I just pay an environmental penalty notice?

Not automatically. Payment in full in accordance with the notice generally prevents further proceedings for the alleged offence, subject to the applicable withdrawal and court-election provisions. Payment is not an admission of liability for a civil claim arising from the occurrence. It does not resolve separate offences or other liabilities preserved by law. Before deciding whether to pay or elect to go to court, check the evidence, election deadline, potential penalties and costs, and any wider consequences for the compliance record.

What is an enforceable undertaking and when is it available?

An enforceable undertaking is a written commitment given to the regulator under environment protection legislation, in EPA matters usually section 253A of the Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997 (NSW), that may include remediation, systems work, monitoring and environmental projects. The EPA has a discretion whether to accept it, publishes guidelines on when it will, and can enforce a breach through the Land and Environment Court. Once the EPA has accepted an undertaking it is generally unlikely to prosecute the same conduct, but that depends on the undertaking being carried out and on no further offences being identified or committed, so an undertaking should not be assumed to end the matter. Every situation turns on its circumstances, the Act the undertaking is given under and the terms the regulator accepts. Any proposal should therefore state precisely what the regulator is and is not agreeing to do and be assessed alongside the evidence and possible proceedings.

Where to start

Facing an investigation or prosecution?

Start with a brief outline of the investigation, penalty notice or prosecution. On a short preliminary call we can tell you whether we can assist and what the first step would be.

Request a call back

Speak with a lawyer

30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge

The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake. Tell us any date stated in the documents. Do not assume that sending an enquiry or making a booking protects a deadline. Ask us to confirm the work we have agreed to undertake, including any action about a deadline. If a date is close or uncertain, seek prompt legal advice rather than waiting for an online reply. Please provide only a brief outline and the names of the relevant parties for the initial enquiry. Keep confidential or privileged documents to hand until we tell you how to provide them.

Speak with a lawyer Call